Re: mystery material removal

Posted by Jennifer Weinbrecht on July 16, 2003 at 22:23:04:

In Reply to: Re: mystery material removal posted by Gordon England on July 16, 2003 at 19:16:44:

: : Has anyone ever had a situation where multiple passes (unintentional - apparently due to turntable failing) resulted in a band of missing material of the substrate, discovered after stripping? The band of missing material is about 0.002 inch lower than surrounding substrate where multiple passes did not occur. There was only one pre-heat pass. Not sure when turntable stopped during 12 passes. Tungsten Carbide on Mirage 250, air plasma spray. Very strange.

: Hi Jennifer

: Yes, very strange. I would be inclined first to check that the original dimensions were in fact correct. Check that the grit blasting prior to spraying was ok ( area being over blasted ). Check that the material was not removed during coating stripping. I can't see the plasma spraying having anything to do with this, particularly as the area is not associated with the excessive coating build-up. Could component distortion from localised overheating be confused with material loss?

: Hope this helps

: Regards Gordon

Hi Gordon,
Thanks for prompt attention to my question. Sorry this next message is so long, but here is more information:

OD is on a turbine rotor shaft, about 5 inch diameter. Two pilot diameters about an inch away from each other, one is about 3/4 inch wide, one about 1/2 inch wide. First, the diameters were ground for coating and were "0" runout, then inspected, shot peened, and plasma sprayed. At finish grind, the coating was cracked, so the shaft went to chem strip for a plasma rework. After chem strip, it was inspected and was a consistent surface. It went to plasma dept for mask, grit blast prep, and spray. Again went to the grinder for finish grind. Grinder had "lack of fill" in one inch band across both diameters, but, strangely, also had heavy overspray adjacent to lack of fill. Again went to chem strip for rework. As coating stripped, "bull's-eye" discoloration on parent material and band of missing material appeared. Band is up to 0.013 lower than "0" surface on larger pilot diameter and registers spike on eddy current. We are simulating pattern on a scrap shaft today, by stopping the turntable during the passes, the coating built up and fell off, and we are creating blue discoloration on the shaft, but will need to strip it to see if we have the "low spot" we're talking about. The band is distinctly demarcated, with a little ridge along the edge of each side of it, and we have some "ripples" along the diameter next to the low spots.

Yeah, we looked at blasting, etc, but it really seems to have happened during the spray operation.

However, in all these many years, none of us have seen this pattern. Would you like to see a picture?


Follow Ups:

Surface Engineering Forum

Surface Engineering Message Board Archive

Surface Engineering Message Board Archive Index

Post A Message!

Gordon England Surface Engineering ForumPlease go to the new Surface Engineering Forum as this old message board is a read only archive. Please copy and paste relevant information or link to the page if you wish to reactivate a thread on the new forum.

Gordon England Independent Thermal Spray Coating Consultant
Telephone: +44 (0)1252 405186


Site Links


Nature of Thermal Spray Coatings

Surface Engineering in a Nutshell

Surface Engineering Forum

Thermal Spray Gun Repair Service

Plasma Consumable Parts

Thermal Spray Powder Supplies


Thermal Spray Coatings on Carbon and Glass Fibre Reinforced Polymers

HVOF Coating of Paper Making Roll

Abradable Coatings


Thermal Spray Processes:

Combustion Wire Thermal Spray Process

Combustion Powder Thermal Spray Process

Arc Wire Thermal Spray Process

Plasma Thermal Spray Process

HVOF Thermal Spray Process

HVAF Thermal Spray Process

Detonation Thermal Spray Process

Plasma Flame Theory

Cold Spray Coating Process

Wear and Use of Thermal Spray Coatings

Corrosion and Use of Thermal Spray Coatings

Glossary of Thermal Spray and Surface Engineering Terms

Image Directory for Thermal Spray Coatings

Plasma Gas Flow Information

Plasma Gas Flow Correction Calculator

Contact Form

Links to other interesting sites related to thermal spray and surface engineering

Reciprocal Links

Periodic Table of the Elements

SI Units

Calculators for Conversion between Units of Measurement

Hardness Testing

Surface Engineering Message Board Archive

Surface Engineering Message Board Archive Index

Photography Gallery2

Photography Gallery3

© Copyright Gordon England